Car Passenger can’t be asked demanded for ID
State v Boston (A-4752-17)
In State v Boston, the court just decided that when the driver is arrested it is reasonable to ask the passenger for his license, but not for further ID when he fails to produce a license.
Defendant Dwayne D. Boston was convicted of third-degree possession of cocaine following a routine traffic stop on his way home from the movies with his wife and children. He contends the police unlawfully asked him, a front-seat passenger in his wife's car, to hand over his State identification card after he told them he did not have a driver's license. The court agrees, and concludes defendant's subsequent arrest on an open traffic warrant was unlawful, and the drugs seized in the ensuing search incident to his arrest should have been excluded at trial.
The court holds in a routine traffic stop where the driver has to be arrested on an open traffic warrant, the officer's asking whether a passenger is a licensed driver is reasonable; but when the passenger claims he does not possess a license, the officer's further demand for identification from the unlicensed passenger in the absence of particularized suspicion is not.
