Kenneth Vercammen & Associates, P.C.
2053 Woodbridge Avenue - Edison, NJ 08817
(732) 572-0500 www.njlaws.com
Kenneth Vercammen was included in the “Super Lawyers” list published by Thomson Reuters

Friday, March 06, 2009

03-03-09 State v. Atkins A-4734-05T4

03-03-09 State of New Jersey v. Sidney Atkins
A-4734-05T4

Following the established rule in State v. Mingo, 77 N.J.
576, 586-87 (1978), we find reversible error in allowing the
prosecution to invade the privilege with regard to the defense-
retained consultant. Accordingly "the report and testimony of a
defense-retained expert consultant who will not testify as a
defense witness and whose report will not be utilized as
evidence are not available to the State." Ibid. The
justification that defendant waived the privilege by operation
of N.J.R.E. 607 in introducing the victim's recantation fails
because other evidence was available to the prosecution to rebut
the charge of recent fabrication, improper influence, or motive
which would not have been unduly prejudicial to defendant.