STATE OF NEW JERSEY VS. C.J.L. (19-07-1053, MONMOUTH COUNTY AND STATEWIDE) (RECORD IMPOUNDED) (A-1052-21)
Defendant's bedroom was searched pursuant to a warrant after law enforcement received cyber tips about emails and Instagram messages containing images of child endangerment which were linked to an email address which incorporated defendant's last name and first initial. Among other devices, officers retrieved a cell phone from defendant's bedroom, but were unable to access the cell phone because it was passcode protected. The State filed a motion to compel production of the passcode by defendant. The Law Division denied the motion, finding the State failed to establish defendant's ownership of the phone. The State appealed.
The court held that the motion court erred by misapplying the foregone conclusion standard set forth in State v. Andrews, 243 N.J. 447 (2020), which established a testimonial exception to a defendant's right against self - incrimination under the United States Constitution as well as in New Jersey statutory and common-law. The court also held that the motion court erred by overlooking facts in the record which were probative on the issue of defendant's ownership or possession of the cell phone.
